The Star Wars sequel trilogy remains one of the most successful yet divisive chapters in the franchise, earning over $1 billion per film while sparking ongoing backlash from fans. Critics praised The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi, but many longtime viewers still question key story choices and now point back to creator George Lucas as a missed opportunity.
When Lucas sold Lucasfilm to Disney in 2012, he handed over story outlines for Episodes VII through IX. Disney chose a different direction, but several of Lucas’s ideas still made it to the screen. These included Luke Skywalker living in exile, a young female Jedi who became Rey, and the continued presence of Imperial loyalists after the Empire’s fall.
One major difference was the political structure. In The Force Awakens, audiences were left confused about how the First Order, the New Republic, and the Resistance all fit together. Lucas had planned a clearer arc focused on rebuilding the Republic after Return of the Jedi, showing a galaxy struggling through years of instability and power vacuums.
That chaos would have paved the way for a familiar villain. Lucas intended to bring back Darth Maul as the central antagonist of the trilogy. The groundwork for Maul’s return had already been laid in Star Wars: The Clone Wars. In Lucas’s version, Maul would lead criminal factions and challenge the fragile Republic.
Maul was also set to train an apprentice named Darth Talon, a character pulled from the Expanded Universe. Disney instead created Kylo Ren, a fallen son of Han Solo and Leia Organa, though similarities to earlier expanded stories remain clear.
Lucas’s outline also placed Leia Organa at the center of the saga. He envisioned her as the true chosen one who would bring balance by restoring political order as Chancellor. This idea tied together threads from The Empire Strikes Back and the prequel trilogy, shifting the focus of the entire nine-film arc.
Disney’s version still gave Leia a leadership role, but her story was cut short after Carrie Fisher’s death in 2016. The films instead leaned heavily on Rey as the central hero, a move that drew criticism from some fans who argued the franchise had shifted too far from its original focus.
Lucas also planned to expand on one of his most controversial ideas, the midi-chlorians. In a 2018 interview, he described a deeper exploration of microscopic life forms called the Whills, which he said control the universe and connect all living things through the Force.
The concept dates back to early drafts of Star Wars and later appeared in Star Wars: The Clone Wars. Lucas suggested future films might explore this hidden layer of reality, though it remains unclear how far he would have taken the idea on screen.
Disney ultimately avoided this direction, likely aware of how divisive such concepts could be. While the company has continued to expand the franchise with series like Star Wars: Rebels and new Maul-focused stories, it has largely stayed away from Lucas’s more experimental ideas.
The debate over what could have been continues to shape fan discussion. The sequel trilogy delivered massive box office results, but questions about its creative choices and long-term impact on the franchise remain unresolved.
***
English (US) · 